Rau Traditional Market Cleanliness: Whose Responsibility is it?
Rau Traditional Market Cleanliness: Whose Responsibility is it?
Group 1
- Luh Nityaswari Laba (1001220166)
- Eois Tri Wahyuni (1001220138)
- Annisa Atika Irwan (1001220100)
- Mujahidah Adawiah (1001220234)
- Ghina Yumna Kamila (1001220193)
Outline
· Introduction
·
General
opening
The market is a place
where sellers and consumers negotiate with each other to achieve their
respective goals. In today's increasingly modern era, many millennial
housewives refuse and are hesitant to shop at the market, particularly
traditional markets, which are often crowded. Explore one of the markets in the
heart of Serang, the Rau Traditional Market, which is still used for bargaining
and getting a variety of food and clothing. Rau Market is rarely visited today
for a variety of reasons, including the fact that it is filthy and the streets
surrounding it are littered with potholes and trash cans. What is the actual
state of the Rau market? How do traders and buyers react to the cleanliness of
the Rau market? What
is the reason why Rau market cleanliness is so bad? Who is responsible for the
cleanliness of the market?
·
Specific
Instance
Rau Traditional Market Cleanliness
Condition
·
Thesis
statement
There are some people who have
responsibility for Rau Traditional market cleanliness
· Arguments:
Rau Traditional Market Cleanliness: Whose Responsibility is it?
a. Seller
b. Customers
c. Government
·
Conclusion
Timeline Progress Observation:
FIRST DRAFT
Rau Traditional Market Cleanliness: Whose Responsibility is it?
 |
| Potholes in Rau Traditional Market |
- Traditional market located in South Tangerang, Banten, precisely behind Plaza Ciputat.
- Yangapi traditional market which is located on Jl. Raya Besakih, Yangapi, Kec. Tembuku, Bangli Regency, Bali.
- Cisalak Market which is located on Jalan Raya Bogor Km 31, Cisalak, Cimanggis sub-district, Depok City, West Java.
- The Kemiri Muka traditional market which is located in Beji District, Depok City, West Java
I believe that traditional markets that are slums and fail to preserve the cleanliness of the environment described above do not merit praise or even just an awareness of the justifications given for why the market is so filthy and disorganized in every article and news item that examines them. The management of traditional markets, modern markets, and the direction of street sellers in North Barito Regency are governed by the Regional Regulation of North Barito Regency Number 1 of 2013; for more information, read Chapter IV: Market Management, Part One: Traditional Market. Traditional markets must comply with the conditions set forth in Establishment and Development, Article 9, Paragraph 1 (c), one of which is "offering facilities that guarantee a clean traditional market, healthy (hygienic), safe, orderly, and comfortable public areas." (Mulyawan, Agus. 2015) Therefore, it is not unavoidable that when a market is created, it must adhere to these statutory rules for cleanliness in order to prevent the emergence of unkempt, filthy, or traditional markets. foul odor, too. However, despite the fact that it is frequently observed that many traditional markets still appear dirty rather than orderly and tidy.
Rau Market is a typical market that attracts a lot of customers, and traders complain bitterly about its lack of sanitation. The sanitation in the Rau market, according to Bu Ami, the egg vendor there, is very limited because of the volume of customers and the absence of cleaning workers. Because the cleaning charge is also beneficial to the general welfare, it is frequently paid. The scattered chests at the Rau market will then be transported using the cleaning funds. On the other hand, Pa Dedi, the Rau market's parking attendant, claimed that certain areas of the market, including the clothing kiosks, were deemed to be clean. Pa Dedi also added that in the Rau market there is also a security fee, which will later be used to ensure the security of the market and the traders.
Rau traditional market conditions are disturbing when they are not managed according to procedures and when community behavior does not keep the market clean and in order. People feel that the government is not paying attention to the status of the Rau traditional market, which is the hub of Serang City's traditional market and should be handled correctly because the government's market rehabilitation project has not been fully accomplished. The Rau traditional market needs continuous revitalization by the government. The infrastructure, amenities, and market facilities need to be improved as much as possible. Additionally, it's important to revitalize the area at the proper moment, particularly during the dry season. Some vendors noted that because the market restoration process was always done during the rainy season, the restored roads were prone to potholes and mud when it rained. By collaboratively keeping the market clean and organized, the people, as the market's producers and customers, must likewise be mindful of themselves. Clean the market frequently and dispose of trash where it belongs; don't always count on cleaners. Along with maintaining the market's cleanliness, the neighborhood must also keep an eye on its stalls and cars. The community and the government must work together to implement regulations that will keep the Rau traditional market clean and orderly in order to achieve this goal.
FINAL DRAFT
Rau Traditional Market Cleanliness: Whose Responsibility is it?
|
| Potholes in Rau Traditional Market |
The market is a place where sellers and
consumers negotiate with each other to achieve their respective goals. In
today's increasingly modern era, many millennial housewives refuse and are
hesitant to shop at the market, particularly traditional markets, which are
often crowded. Explore one of the markets in the heart of Serang, the Rau
Traditional Market, which is still used for bargaining and getting a variety of
food and clothing. Rau Market is rarely visited today for a variety of reasons,
including the fact that it is filthy and the streets surrounding it are
littered with potholes and trash cans. What is the actual state of the Rau
market? How do traders and buyers react to the cleanliness of the Rau market? What is the reason why Rau market cleanliness
is so bad? Who is responsible for the cleanliness of the market?
- Sellers
"Why are sellers responsible for the cleanliness of the market?" The current condition of Rau market cleanliness is quite dirty and there is minimal awareness of traders about the scattered garbage generated from the traders' places. According to Mr. Sutarto, one of the parking attendants there, he believes that traders must be responsible for the waste generated after trading, at least cleaning their respective places. We have the same opinion as him; the cleanliness of the market is of course the responsibility of traders too because traders use public facilities and places to trade. Even though traders pay fees for cleaning workers, the responsibility cannot be fully transferred to cleaning workers. It is the traders who produce waste in the market, so they must have responsibility and awareness for the cleanliness of the market.
- Customers
Customers, as the most frequent
market visitors, must realize the importance of keeping the market environment
clean. Not only are sellers and janitors expected to keep the market clean, but
customers must also maintain the cleanliness of the market environment.
Customers certainly realize that market cleanliness will make them comfortable when
shopping. For this reason, buyers, as frequent market visitors, must have their
own awareness and initiative to maintain cleanliness. As said by one of the
buyers at the Rau market, Ibu Lilis (35), who is aware of market cleanliness,
"In my opinion, our society lacks awareness of the importance of
maintaining cleanliness." They only expect the roles of traders and market
cleaners because they have the principle that market cleaners receive a salary
and that is their job, while maintaining cleanliness is a shared
responsibility. In our opinion, as customers, we must know the importance of
keeping the environment clean. We definitely want convenience when shopping.
For this reason, we, as customers, must be aware of our obligation to keep the
market clean. The main thing that buyers can do is not litter or bring garbage
into the market environment. Having awareness about keeping the market clean is
very important, because if there is no self-awareness and initiative to
maintain cleanliness, it is difficult to make it happen.
- . Government
The market is a social facility that exists, managed, and supervised by the government. It is not surprising that many argue that market cleanliness is the responsibility of the government. "In my opinion, the government is responsible for cleaning the market. We traders are asked to pay a fee of 12.000 rupiahs every month to pay cleaning staff. So it is no longer our responsibility." said a trader in the Rau market. According to the traders, because they have already paid a fee for cleaning the market, they do not have any responsibility regarding the cleanliness of the market. so, they don't have the awareness to just tidy up their merchandise booth after selling even though there is a lot of trash scattered around it, there are also leftover foods, rotten fruits, or fish scales and excrement which then invites bad smells and makes lots of insects too flies scattered around the market. According to the regional regulation of north Barito regency number 1 of 2013; chapter IV: market management, part one: traditional market. Traditional markets must comply with the conditions set forth in establishment and development, article 9 paragraph 1 (c), one of which is "Offering facilities that guarantee a clean, healthy (hygienic) traditional market, safe, orderly, and comfortable public areas. " The regulation is indeed sufficient to make the responsibility for cleaning the market a government obligation. Namely providing facilities that ensure the cleanliness of the market. And as proof, the government has organized market cleaning officers, but with the extent of the market, and also the amount of waste generated by traders and market visitors, it is a very difficult job if market cleanliness is only burdened or is the task of market cleaners.
The market is a social facility that exists, managed, and supervised by the government. It is not surprising that many argue that market cleanliness is the responsibility of the government. According to the traders, because they have already paid a fee for cleaning the market, they do not have any responsibility regarding the cleanliness of the market. so, they don't have the awareness to just tidy up their merchandise booth after selling even though there is a lot of trash scattered around it, there are also leftover foods, rotten fruits, or fish scales and excrement which then invites bad smells and makes lots of insects too flies scattered around the market. Namely providing facilities that ensure the cleanliness of the market.
Photovoice:
 |
| Scan Me for Photovoice! |
 |
| Group one exhibition |
 |
| Scan this for other's photo! |
Documentation:
Ernawan, Randi. (2017). "Pasar Tradisional di Ciputat Sepi Pengunjung Karena Kumuh dan Kotor". Jakarta: Pusfaster.
Mulyawan, Agus. (2015). "Pasar tradisional memperhatikan". Jakarta: Media Indonesia.
I
Comments
Post a Comment